Best Pizza in Siesta Key

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Siesta Key

Pizza is on many people’s list of things to eat, no matter where in the world they travel. Italians swear their pizza is the best and only kind that matters. New Yorkers swear their pizza is the best while Chicagoans will yet claim to have the most amazing slices. 

Siesta Key Pizza Restaurants

On Siesta Key, pizza takes on a new flavor and variety. Sarasota offers a wide range of stylish pizza dining spots to out-of-the-way places with some of the best slices in the south. Check out a few of the best pizzas in Siesta Key.

Il Panificio Siesta Key

Grab a quick bite at this beautiful eatery. Expansion to Siesta Key happened only recently. With two other locations, this one is by far taking pizza to the next level. Order whole pizzas or slices served New York style. Mix and match toppings or try something brand new. Enjoy regular toppings along with breakfast pizza (yes, please) topped with a mix of egg, veggies, cheese, bacon, and more. Why stop at pizza for dinner? Try a dessert pizza to end the night on a high note with flavors like caramel apple, what’s not to like?

  • 215 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key
  • (941) 800-5570; 

Other Locations

  • 1703 Main St., Sarasota – (941) 366-5570;
  • 2053 Reynolds St., Sarasota – (941) 921-5570;


Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar Siesta Key

Flavio’s is a fan favorite around Siesta Key. Great pasta and Italian entrees are just the starts of an amazing and flavorful menu. Pizza is, of course, one of the top offerings. Cooked in a brick oven, ingredients are mostly traditional Italian but look out for other types of pizza like Hawaiian, also. Be sure to check out their spot on Main Street (no pizza served here). Enjoy a taste of Italy right in Siesta Key.

  • 5239 Ocean Blvd., Siesta Key, Sarasota
  • (941) 349-0995

Ripfire Pizza & BBQ

Let’s rip at this amazing pizza & BBQ joint right in the heart of Siesta Key Village. No games are being played here with ingredients fresh from Naples, Italy. Pulled pork is smoked in-house with a signature rub. Craft beers flow readily from the tap and include craft beers from local faves in Sarasota and Bradenton areas. Gluten-free pizza and beer are also available for discerning customers. Customize the pizza or try a new pie like the Heat Wave pizza with pulled pork. Fresh, fired, and fast is how they roll the dough at Ripfire Pizza & BBQ – a place sure to keep visitors coming back for more.

  • 5218 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
  • (941) 313 – 7511


Pizza N' Brew Siesta Key

Take pizza and add craft beer and voila! Pizza N’ Brew is born. New York-style slices and pies take the cake at this Siesta Key location in the heart of the island. The food menu includes 36-taps of domestic and craft brews, wine, and a full liquor bar. Weekly events include live music and DJs on the weekends to keep brews flowing and slices eaten. Fresh ingredients and generous servings keep visitors coming back for seconds (and thirds).

  • 6645 Midnight Pass Rd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
  • (941) 349-4490


Local Resources

YOLO Parasailing & Adventures

Adventure sports, Parasailing ride service, Boat tour agency, Fishing charter, Sightseeing tour agency

135 Bridge St
    Bradenton Beach, Florida 34217

More Info

Siesta Key Aqua Adventures

Canoe & kayak rental service, Adventure sports, Amusement center, Boat tour agency, Outdoor activity organiser, Parasailing ride service, Rafting, Theme park, Tourist attraction, Water sports equipment rental service

5253 S Tamiami Trail
    Sarasota, Florida 34231

More Info

CB's Saltwater Outfitters

Boat rental service, Bait shop, Clothing store, Fishing charter, Fishing store, Golf cart dealer, Parasailing ride service

1249 Stickney Point Rd
    Siesta Key, Florida 34242

More Info

Siesta Key Watersports

Boat rental service, Parasailing ride service, Boat tour agency, Sightseeing tour agency, Tourist attraction

1536 Stickney Point Rd
    Sarasota, Florida 34231

More Info

YOLO Parasailing & Adventures

Adventure sports, Parasailing ride service, Boat tour agency, Fishing charter, Sightseeing tour agency

4110 127th St W
    Cortez, Florida 34215

More Info